Tomaso Sanelli on the Fun, Rollercoaster Journey that is ‘Overcompensating’ on Prime Video

Our latest feature for Popternative Magazine is with actor Tomaso Sanelli who plays Trent in the new comedy drama series, Overcompensating. The Benito Skinner-led and created series dropped on Prime Video last month an. Overcompensating follows the chaotic journey of a closeted former football player as he navigates his first year at college. After becoming an instant coming-of-age hit, fans are eagerly waiting to hear about a second season, but a series renewal has yet to be announced.

In our exclusive chat, Tomaso talks about his audition process for the series, working with Benito and the ensemble cast, and some memorable on set stories. He discusses his role in Eli Roth’s hit 2023 horror film, Thanksgiving, and working in the horror genre.

Exclusive photos for Popternative Magazine by Mike NG of Evoke Photo Studios

What was your audition process like for Overcompensating?

Tomaso: The audition process was a little bit different than what I was used to. I auditioned four times for four different characters. On the third tape, I was like, “What am I doing wrong?” Then, when they sent the fourth and I figured I must have been doing something right. I definitely felt more confident going into it. It’s so strange how these things work out. 

What was it like reading the scenes with your character, Trent, and then seeing them come to life on screen?

Tomaso: When I first read the scenes with my character, I recognized the behaviour and way of speaking in so many ‘dudes’ who I’ve had encounters with. It’s over the top, and yet all so real— this is actually how they talk. Sidebar— some folks might see these guys as caricatures. Maybe they’re right, and also, that’s the point, and it doesn’t take away from how well written and accurate these scenarios are. These guys are constantly overcompensating for each other. There’s room for growth in season 2!

As far as seeing the show, I was so happy. It’s always been strange for me to watch myself on the screen. With this one, however, I actually felt like I could detach from that meta cringe and just enjoy the show. It’s hilarious and painfully accurate. I still cringed, but in the way it was intended. Watching it now, I’m mainly grateful to be a part of the whole ecosystem. 

What was it like working with the Overcompensating cast?

Tomaso: Working with the cast was unreal. With the amount of comedians on set, it was high octane and full of laughs. These people are legitimately so sharp and hilarious on and off screen. A lot of actors understandably conserve their energy while off camera, and sometimes the ‘in between’ can be less chatty and more meditative, especially in Canada. This time, conversations were plenty, more real, and just way more fun. I learned a lot from them. I was in and out of set, but always eager to be back in. 

Are there any memorable stories from set you can share with us?

Tomaso: I mean, the whole duration of filming felt like a long story playing out, getting to know my cast-mates and watching the series take shape. One really memorable moment was the Halloweekend episode. Originally, we weren’t in it, but that ended up being one of the most fun days. I don’t remember exactly how it played out, but we asked Benny and our show-runner Scott King if the F and G guys should be at the chem party. One day I asked Benny again and he said “Congratulations, you’re a penis!” Yes, I literally got paid to wear a penis costume and hang out with cool people. I love my job.

Thanksgiving was a big horror hit; what was it like to work on a horror film that has had such an impact on the genre?

Tomaso: Yes it was! It was honestly one of the greatest experiences of my life so far. It felt surreal, and my castmates and I all agree in hindsight. It was a month of pure fun. Lots of hard work, and so many long days, but we enjoyed every moment of it. It’s been really cool to see the reaction and the impact it had on the horror landscape. I’m seeing plenty more original slashers with young ensemble casts being made, and it makes me really happy. 

What do you enjoy the most about working in the horror genre? 

Tomaso: Working in horror is amazing. It’s a lot more fun than you might think. Horror people have the best sense of humor— on set, if you’re crying and screaming one minute, you’re dying of laughter the next. In the moment it’s so much fun, but equally as awe-inspiring. The precision people work with in horror blows my mind. Every department on set has to go extra hard from the set design to the makeup (including the prosthetics department) just to name a few. These people bring the genre to life, and they inspire me to do my best on set. Ok now I’m ready for the next one.

Lastly, I have to mention that the response from fans and the passion people have for the genre is amazing. I went to my first horror convention in October and met some great people. They appreciate the details, and you can tell through the questions they ask. I’ll definitely be going to more of them soon. 

_

Overcompensating is streaming on Prime Video.

Follow Tomaso Sanelli: Instagram
Follow Popternative Magazine: Instagram