Seekers of Infinite Love Review (SXSW)
Seekers of Infinite Love has something for everyone—especially those who have siblings. By anchoring a wild, high-stakes premise in the recognizable bickering of three siblings, the film avoids the trap of feeling far-fetched, delivering instead a heartfelt and hilarious exploration of what it means to show up for family—even when you’d rather be anywhere else.
The film introduces us to the Bachman siblings, a trio who have a lot of baggage but on their own and as a group, which makes for a very entertaining film. There’s Kayla (Hannah Einbinder), an author who can write about human emotion but struggles to actually feel it; Zach (John Reynolds), a lawyer clinging to a fading dream of folk stardom; and Wes (Griffin Gluck), a graphic novelist battling the dual demons of gambling and pills. When their younger sister Scarlett vanishes into the “Seekers of Infinite Love” cult, this fractured unit is forced back together by their absent parents and a cult deprogrammer, Rick Delacroix (Justin Theroux).
What follows is a road trip movie that feels both fresh and nostalgic. As a fan of the cult documentary subgenre, something the film hilariously acknowledges—I was initially drawn in by the intrigue of a deprogramming mission. However, once the movie started I was hooked because of the hilarious dynamic between these siblings, Theroux’s performance, and the relatability of a family who, of course, loves each other deep down.
The strength of Seekers of Infinite Love lies almost entirely in its cast. The chemistry between Einbinder, Gluck, and Reynolds is electric, capturing that specific brand of sibling shorthand where a single look can communicate a lifetime of resentment or a buried joke. Every so often something from their past is brought up, and each time it is hilarious. As someone who is a sibling myself, and has two kids, I instantly related to the feelings that are shown on screen.
Theroux might not play one of the siblings, but that doesn’t mean his character isn’t a part of the story. He is wildly unpredictable, which makes him one of the most exciting pieces of the puzzle. He is quirky, eccentric, and delivers one of his best roles in years – if not ever. I want to avoid spoilers, but know there are some truly great moments with him towards the end of the film. It is safe to say he was having a great time filming this one.
Seekers of Infinite Love also succeeds because it never crosses the line and becomes too wild. Sure, there are some crazy things that happen during this road trip, but in the end, it really is about the bond between siblings, and that grounds the story. The writing, while perhaps not perfect in its pacing, excels in its dialogue. The comedic beats are hit with precision, particularly during the scenes of sibling bickering. It’s in these moments that the film feels most relatable.
This movie keeps the audience guessing, not just about whether they will save Scarlett (Justine Lupe), but about how this family will survive one another. It’s unpredictable and wild, yet it maintains a tether to emotional truth. While the journey is filled with unexpected comedic detours, the third act is surprisingly poignant. I found myself getting unexpectedly emotional toward the end.
Overall Thoughts
Seekers of Infinite Love is a hilarious, moving, and brilliantly acted film. It takes a premise that could have been a dark thriller and turns it into a celebration of the messy bonds of kinship. It’s a testament to the fact that even when the writing hits a few bumps in the road, a stellar ensemble can drive the story home.
Rating: ★★★⯪☆
Seekers of Infinite Love had its premiere at SXSW 2026.
_
Tessa Smith is a Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer-approved Film and TV Critic. She owns Mama’s Geeky, but also is a freelance writer. Tessa has been in the Entertainment writing business for more than ten years and is a member of several Critics Associations including the Critics Choice Association. Her passion for film, television, video games, and comic books started when she was a little girl and has only continued to grow.