Roofman Review
Whenever a film says “based on a true story”, it’s often hard to believe that such a thing can happen. There have been recent films that have done this, from The Lost Bus to Warfare, that bring these real stories to the dramatized world of movies. However, one of those films genuinely feels like it’s bordering on not being real at all: Roofman. In a surprising turn of events, it turns out that not only was Roofman’s narrative legitimately real, but its self-contained story is a grounded tragedy of its own.
Roofman is based on the real life escapades of Jeffrey Manchester (Channing Tatum), former Army reserve officer-turned-criminal. Escaping prison and on the verge of getting caught, Manchester hides in a large compartment of an operating Toys “R” Us store. But when he finds himself fascinated by Leigh Wainscott (Kirsten Dunst), a struggling single mother, Manchester must decide whether or not to make his getaway or embrace a new family life.
Of course, given how Roofman’s narrative is inspired by real world events, some things can be further dramatized. This usually takes the form of the film’s more explosive sequences, which have this comedic charm to them that can make you chuckle a bit. The editing from Jim Helton and Ron Patane really helps to accentuate those moments, particularly in the transition between the second and third act. Although, there are some familial moments that are paced in a way that may rush through the dramatics of them somewhat quickly.
Director Derek Cianfrance makes sure to retain the emotional spirit of Manchester’s life. At points, its third-person narration from Tatum’s Manchester can be too explanatory in the moment, but it doesn’t take away from keeping you engaged. Rather, it’s the physical actions of Manchester’s actions in that tiny space that he somehow makes his “home” that breathes energy into the film. Tatum’s sincere performance truly makes you care about Manchester and not just because the real guy was also empathetic in real life.
In fact, Tatum is able to both emphasize Manchester’s nonchalant curiosity while infusing subtlety into the more tongue-biting scenes. This gradually shows itself as Manchester decides to get more loose with himself as he gets himself used to the system he’s established. However, when he’s eventually forced to come to terms with his cynical friend, Steve (LaKeith Stanfield), Tatum is able to push himself further with what he’s got.
Furthermore, Tatum’s chemistry with Dunst simply makes this film very entertaining. Both of them share this lasting nostalgia for connection that bonds their characters together in a way that makes us feel good. In the more comedic moments that involve Leigh’s church friends, Ron (Ben Mendelsohn) and Eileen (Uzo Aduba), Tatum and Dunst bounce off of each other really well. It’s unfortunate then, when the film reaches its troubling climax, it feels like it’s somewhat downplayed for an “in the moment” situation.
Still, it’s the family-centric aspects of Roofman that really carry this film. Though Cianfrance bounces through some familiar ups and downs with Manchester’s “new” family, it tries to do its best through realistic dialogue to keep it relatable. Yet, it also feels somewhat trope-y to have that growing angst driven by the parental substitute dynamic formed here. Sure, it doesn’t necessarily have that substantial payoff to see how Leigh’s daughters coped after the fact. Nonetheless, Cianfrance does his best to make sure that you still feel for Leigh, her kids, and her peers to make it pleasant.
Roofman is a sincerely sweet, if chaotically hilarious, retelling of a real life incident that’s simply entertaining thanks to the deep performances from Channing Tatum and Kirsten Dunst. Though it might be hard to believe that this was actually a real story with real consequences, this film picks out the important things that make it emotionally resonate with audiences.
Roofman releases in theaters on October 10.
Rating: ★★★★
_
Christopher Gallardo is a freelance entertainment writer and critic. While not running The Reel Roller, Chris can be found writing reviews and breakdowns on all things films and TV. Outside of entertainment writing, he’s currently taking classes for a Bachelor’s of Science with a minor in Digital Media & Journalism. Plus, he loves Percy Jackson, animated films and shows, and Fallout! Follow Christopher on Instagram & X.
Roofman Review
Roofman Review